Throughout their respective histories, Shanghai and
Ningbo have been inextricably linked, each viewing the other
as similar yet distinct, like a reflection through a warped
mirror. These two cities -- once two of the busiest ports on
the East China Sea -- sit symmetrically to the north and south
of Hangzhou Harbor.
The Ningbo and Shanghai connection goes beyond mere
geography and economics. Ningbo was a booming center of trade
as early as the Tang Dynasty (AD 618-907), and by the
sixteenth century was welcoming goods and silver from as far
away as Spain and Portugal. One British trader wrote of Ningbo
in 1832, "It surpasses anything Chinese which we have yet
seen, in the regularity and magnificence of the buildings, and
is behind none in mercantile fame."
Ningbo was the site of the second battle of the First Opium
War (1840-42), falling after Guangzhou (Canton) succumbed to
British gunboats. When under the terms of the Treaty of
Nanjing Britain was given the right to select five treaty
ports, Ningbo was an obvious choice -- much more so than
Shanghai. But as Shanghai developed, Ningbo's fortunes
declined, and its hold on the region's trade increasingly
slipped over to its sister. Shanghai's new status as China's
leading port drew to it the savvy, experienced businessmen
from Ningbo and Guangzhou, the two cities that once competed
for that title. Many of the people who now consider themselves
Shanghainese migrated from Zhejiang Province three to five
generations ago, and of them the largest proportion hails from
Ningbo. In the first half of the twentieth century, the Ningbo
Guild was second only to the Green Gang in influence, and the
modern Shanghainese dialect derives many of its patterns from
Ningbo speech.
Modern day Ningbo is a peaceful, subdued city where
past and present coexist unselfconsciously. It manages to
remain free of the crowded urban ugliness that permeates most
China's cities. It is a city of broad, tree-lined lanes
criss-crossed by a network of rivers, where one can cross town
by bicycle rickshaw for 5 yuan. Only a handful of the city's
major intersections sport traffic lights, with the rest
relying on an honor system: Please dodge carefully and try not
to hit anyone. Downtown, a Song Dynasty tower neighbors a
Soviet-style factory and overlooks an urban landscape of
high-rises jutting up awkwardly from the Qing courtyard houses
that surround them.
Ningbo can serve as a comfortable launching pad for touring
the numerous temples, towers, lakes and mountains within a
two-hour radius in the surrounding Zhejiang countryside. The
city itself, however, contains more than enough to fill up a
laid-back weekend. Although the Cultural Revolution struck
particularly hard in Ningbo, damaging many of the historic
buildings and looting most of their contents, the city is now
taking extensive measures to protect what remains and, in some
cases, recreate what was destroyed.
Most notable, and best preserved, of Ningbo's
sights is the Tian Yi Ge imperial archives, located on
Changchun Lu. A sprawling compound with dozens of ornate
buildings and numerous exquisite gardens, Tian Yi Ge requires
the better part of an afternoon to fully explore. Only a
smattering of the books and archives remain, so many of the
buildings instead contain exhibitions on Ningbo's history and
traditional crafts. Over four hundred years old, Tian Yi Ge
figured as one of Zhejiang's most important centers of
government and scholarship under the Ming and Qing Dynasties.
It was also the site of recreation for imperial ministers,
attested to by the compound's glitteringly gilded opera stage.
An extra 5 RMB will let you climb onto the stage for a view of
its swirling red and gold ceiling, and for a higher surcharge
you can even rent opera costumes for the ultimate cheesy photo
op.
A few blocks east of Tian Yi Ge lies the long,
narrow Moon Lake (Yue Hu) and its surrounding Moon Lake Park.
Despite the absence of gates and entrance fees, the park is
clean and peaceful, and its patrons actually leave their trash
in the garbage cans rather than on the sidewalk. Old-style
teahouses dotting the shore of the lake do brisk business.
Jutting into the lake from its northern point is the Guandi
Temple. The temple was gutted in its entirety during the
Cultural Revolution, but in 1994 the city's devout took up a
collection to restore the building. The new Guandi Temple is
thus filled with new and not particularly picturesque statues,
but worshipers are plentiful and the place is interestingly
administered not by monks but by retired, blue-coated
townspeople who volunteer their time.
A number of small streets run off from Moon Lake Park, and
are worth wandering down for the gray brick courtyard houses
typical of East China in the Ming Dynasty that populate them.
This type of building once predominated in Shanghai as well,
but was replaced early on by Western architecture, and now the
only remnants that can be found in suburbs like Songjiang are
disappearing fast. Ningbo, in contrast, is making a marked
attempt to preserve these neighborhoods, and most of the
buildings are in very good condition. The city is even
creating replicas of this architecture in parks and other
publications, with attention paid to authenticity down to the
smallest detail. One of these alleys contains the Qingzhen
Mosque, which has served as the center of Ningbo's community
of Muslim traders for almost a thousand years. Originally
constructed in 1003 AD, the current structure dates from 1699,
and renovations in 1987 fixed as much as possible of extensive
damage from the Cultural Revolution. Half of the unassuming
building now houses a children's arts and craft school, but
the rest still functions as a mosque, with women and
unbelievers allowed only as far as the courtyard.
Beyond the mosque and temples, Ningbo also contains quite a
collection of Catholic churches. Portuguese missionaries first
came to Ningbo in 1628, and the Christian influence remains
strong. An enormous Gothic cathedral, sort of a peach-colored
replica of the Xujiahui Cathedral, was constructed downtown
just a few years ago, and its twin spires can be seen from
most parts of the city. More interesting, though, is the Old
Cathedral (Tianzhu Jiaotang), a French Jesuit construction
dating from 1872. The still-functioning Cathedral is an odd
mixture of Chinese and Western architecture, from a distance
indistinguishable from the gray-tiled surroundings except for
the steeple. Located at Waima Lu and Waizhong Lu, by Tongjiang
Bridge, the Cathedral is part of the dilapidated old foreign
enclave, a collection of decaying Art Deco facades running for
a few blocks along Waima Lu and Neima Lu by the river. In
contrast to Shanghai, Ningbo is preserving its Chinese
historical heritage while abandoning the Western remnants to
the slow rot of time.
Zhongshan Lu, Ningbo's main thoroughfare, boasts a monument
that is even more of an architectural bastard than the
Cathedral. Ningbo's Bell Tower was first built in 821 atop the
old city wall. It was replaced by a frilly Ming pagoda in 1434
and, in 1930, a Western-style clock tower was superimposed on
top of the pagoda, and the result is truly bizarre: Tang city
wall topped by Ming pagoda topped by Western clock.
Innocuously gracing a sidewalk, as if it were dropped there by
accident, the Chengtong Tower can be found just down the
street. The cute, five-story brick tower was built during the
Tang Dynasty in 863.
The significantly larger Tianfeng Tower, built
during the Song Dynasty and located on Kaiming Jie near
Jiefang Nan Lu, can be spotted from most parts of downtown. A
? climb to the top allows a fantastic panoramic view of the
city. From the tower, proceed up Kaiming Jie towards Yaoxing
Jie to the huge City God Temple Fair (Chenghuang Miao
Shengchang), a sprawling street market similar to Shanghai's
Yuyuan. In one section, stock up on gifts and souvenirs, such
as a wild array of hats, hairclips, cigarette lighters, and
the freshwater pearls that are the region's specialty, selling
for as low as ? a strand. Head down the street for stall upon
stall of greasy snacks, or turn back onto Kaiming Jie for a
row of nice restaurants.
Ningbo lacks the scenic wonders and tourist draws of
Zhejiang's more popular destinations. If a traveler is looking
for something beyond the frantic rush of sightseeing and crowd
control, however, they could do no better Ningbo for a calm,
peaceful day or weekend away from Shanghai's urban bustle.
Getting There:
Buses are the fastest route, taking a little over three
hours from Shanghai to Ningbo. They cost about ?0 one-way for
an AC bus with lavatory, and leave from the long-distance
station by the North Train Stations. A plush and comfortable
new train shuttles between Shanghai and Ningbo, and the trip
takes over six hours and costs 60 RMB each way. Alternatively,
ferryboats from Shanghai to Ningbo take anywhere from six to
twelve hours and cost between ?0 and ?00. There are also
flights into Ningbo from most cities in China.
Where to Stay:
Ningbo has a slew of three to four star hotels offering
doubles in the range of ?50-?00. A few notables are the
Overseas Chinese Guesthouse (130 Liuhe Jie, 0574-7293175), the
Ningbo Hotel (65 Mayuan Lu, 0574-7321688), the Ningbo Grand
Hotel (82 Zhongshan Lu, 0574-7344201), and the Jinlong Hotel
(South Railway Station, 0574-4318888).